If Crowdsourcing is Evil, This is its Soundtrack

document Crowd Creativity, Distributed Knowledge

If Crowdsourcing is Evil, This is its Soundtrack

Aaron Koblin and Daniel Massey, crowdsourcers extraordinaire, strike again:

TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c4cdf53ef011168ee9b19970c Listed below are links to weblogs that reference If Crowdsourcing is Evil, This is its Soundtrack:

Comments

Very interesting article and debate. No, I do not believe crowd sourcing is evil, I believe it it the purest form of egalitarianism. The design, first and foremost, is what is important; not the title of the designer, the connections he/she have, nor the school he/she graduated from. I founded RYZWEAR.com, a crowd sourced sneaker brand as a way to tap into an ever growing population of free-lance designers who did not want to work in a corporate environment and did not want to spend hours upon hours of "pitching" themselves to companies for project work. The first winner of our contest was an ex-convict (who might struggle to find a job) who was arrested several times due to his graffiti habit. He ended up spending two years in prison. He was living in a basement apartment, in debt to the city of Portland Oregon for $15,000 and trying to make a living as an artist. Handing over to him, a check for $1,000, was one of the most satisfying things I have done in my career. Next month, he will be featured in a retail launch. I believe that the crowd sourcing model is an extremely efficient use of a designers time. If the crowd sourcing model continues to grow, there will be thousands upon thousands of contests and if they are talented and hard working, chances are they will win lots of contests and earn a good living. The designers that I have contact with from RYZwear all appreciate the opportunity. If they win, their picture is on the hang tag of the product and we try to create rock stars out of them.

Posted by: Rob Langstaff | March 11, 2009 at 09:46 PM

You should fix your language. You're not employing designers. You're employing graphic artists. Design is a process, one of the end products is sometimes graphics. Often no graphics are involved at all. The design process cannot be effectively crowdsourced, by it's nature it requires direct and substantial collaboration with the client. Graphic art, on the other hand, is just making images. Make enough of them randomly, and one of them will work. That's what you're doing with crowdsourcing. Bottom line, you can crowdsource a randomizable product. You cannot crowdsource a process. Posted by: J. Jeffryes | March 12, 2009 at 08:10 AM

“there's also the factor of who chooses the artwork and managerial types don't always understand design--in fact rarely understand design.” David, I have experienced this so often. Ultimately this reality does give each of us the opportunity to make sure that we are working in an environment that gives its due to those who are best suited to manage particular elements. Not necessarily the strong point of traditional institutional life! Institutional biography has been a particular interest of mine and that’s where the rubber hits the road! Once one’s own biographical stream starts to peal away from the institution that one has melded with, where ones creative juices are no longer contributing to the overall forward movement of the institution, or one can no longer stand behind the overall direction or working principles, tough decisions have to be made. “then you're starting with a tainted pool of talent rather than a pool of professionals, and the overall quality goes down.” I do not really understand why a stay at home mother would be considered to be tainted. The quality might possibly go down but it could also produce something superior. Is the greater question about principles rather than an open artistic process? Cheers David

Jeff, very interesting but as you stated evil or at least pretty close. The soundtrack has already started to grind away some where in the recesses of my skull. That particular example of crowdsourcing doesn’t do much for a discussion about the possible quality’s thereof though, that’s for sure. And this:http://adage.com/mediaworks/article?article_id=135098 Regards, Alan.

Posted by: alan | March 12, 2009 at 08:31 AM

Having been involved in a logo design process I think you make a very good point Joshua. How could one possibly design a logo not having had an on-going relationship with the client, after all the logo should ideally manifest, in visual form, the complicated internal impulse/impulses of the institution in mind? Were one to follow that train of thought, the only conclusion one could come to would be that those who need a logo and reach to CS for it are going to get a some what more superficial rendering, be extremely lucky or not be worried because the budget is not there and close enough is, well, close enough. I must add that for the most part, the subtleties of logo design, once utilized, are not penetrated by the majority of those who might perceive it as part of a larger document or visual of any other media. So the question, what’s wrong with having different ranks of need. Big budget logo, no problem flash the cash and the professional designer gets the job. Low budget logo, scrape the barrel, and it what it is, some thing that’s stuck on for what its worth! Second question, do CS logo graphic artists have a direct relationship with the client? Alan Posted by: alan | March 12, 2009 at 10:19 AM

@Rob...

we have the same perception... Posted by: watzabatza | March 26, 2009 at 07:52 PM

The good thing about your information is that it is explicit enough for students to grasp. Thanks for your efforts in spreading academic knowledge. Posted by: logo design | August 02, 2009 at 08:39 PM

Rob is right Posted by: Custom Logo Design | December 04, 2009 at 12:20 AM

The good thing about your information is that it is explicit enough for students to grasp. Thanks for your efforts in spreading academic knowledge. Posted by: kraloyun | December 07, 2009 at 03:54 AM

i`m impressed about the content of this blog is awesome. Posted by: buy propecia | January 27, 2010 at 06:35 AM

wo posted a link to it,thanks for sharing!http://www.sellcheapuggs.com Posted by: ugg boots | January 28, 2010 at 02:12 AM

I'm very interesting in this post about If Crowdsourcing is Evil, This is its Soundtrack thanks Posted by: propecia online | February 22, 2010 at 12:08 PM

I just started reading about 'crowdsourcing' its a really interesting topic... I must stay updated on this! Posted by: Memoir Books | February 25, 2010 at 01:36 PM

I love your blog so much, and there are just some differences with others'. Hope there will be more wonderful things in your blog. Happy every day! Posted by: Dissertation Help | February 27, 2010 at 02:06 AM

What a great post! Just one suggestion:If you add some pics, it would be easiler to follow!Cheap Air jordan Posted by: Air Jordan sale | March 04, 2010 at 01:28 AM

David, I have experienced this so often. Ultimately this reality does give each of us the opportunity to make sure that we are working in an environment that gives its due to those who are best suited to manage particular elements. Not necessarily the strong point of traditional institutional life! thanks for sharing this blog Posted by: generic viagra | March 09, 2010 at 08:34 AM

Institutional biography has been a particular interest of mine and that’s where the rubber hits the road! Once one’s own biographical stream starts to peal away from the institution that one has melded with, where ones creative juices are no longer contributing to the overall forward movement of the institution, or one can no longer stand behind the overall direction or working principles, tough decisions have to be made. Posted by: viagra online | March 22, 2010 at 12:21 PM

The www.lowest-rate-loans.com are very useful for people, which would like to organize their career. As a fact, that's easy to get a college loan. Posted by: LucyConrad18 | May 08, 2010 at 04:14 AM

Nice discussion going on here. I like it. Posted by: Custom Logo Design | June 05, 2010 at 12:11 AM

Having been involved in a logo design process I think you make a very good point Joshua. How could one possibly design a logo not having had an on-going relationship with the client, after all the logo should ideally manifest, in visual form, the complicated internal impulse/impulses of the institution in mind? Were one to follow that train of thought, the only conclusion one could come to would be that those who need a logo and reach to CS for it are going to get a some what more superficial rendering, be extremely lucky or not be worried because the budget is not there and close enough is, well, close enough. Posted by: Spring Summer 2010 | July 22, 2010 at 12:29 AM

Summary This article is about the growing popularity of crowdsourcing.

Description An interesting article and an extensive comment stream challenging the merits of crowdsourcing.

Tags: contests, Crowdsourcing, Daniel Massey, design, logo design, Ryzwear.com, sneaker

Events

If Crowdsourcing is Evil, This is its Soundtrack

Comments

Crowdsourcing.org

Categories

Content

Crowdsourcing.org, an initiative by massolution®

Events

Related Content

If Crowdsourcing is Evil, This is its Soundtrack

Comments

Crowdsourcing.org

Categories

Content

Crowdsourcing.org, an initiative by massolution®